From approved sample to delivered lot: writing an acceptance standard that holds
The document that decides a dispute is not the sample on your desk but the acceptance standard you signed before production.
Short answer
- A physical sample answers what the thing looks like.
- External and internal dimensions with tolerance; wall thickness at named points; latch and hinge operation force; gasket compression; colour reference with the tolerance method; liner pocket dimensions; the drop or stack test to be repeated on production samples; packaging configuration; and the marking and labelling layout..
- State the inspection level, the AQL for critical, major and minor defects, and what counts as each.
- Keep two signed samples, one with you and one with the plant, both dated and marked.
The sample is a reference, not a specification
A physical sample answers what the thing looks like. It cannot answer how much variation is acceptable, so it must be converted into a written standard with measured values and tolerances before the first production run.
What the standard should contain
External and internal dimensions with tolerance; wall thickness at named points; latch and hinge operation force; gasket compression; colour reference with the tolerance method; liner pocket dimensions; the drop or stack test to be repeated on production samples; packaging configuration; and the marking and labelling layout.
Sampling plan and AQL
State the inspection level, the AQL for critical, major and minor defects, and what counts as each. Cosmetic scuffing on a surface that faces a wall is not the same defect class as a latch that does not seat. Without that split, every report becomes an argument.
Golden sample custody
Keep two signed samples, one with you and one with the plant, both dated and marked. Photograph the marking. Most batch-does-not-match-sample disputes are actually a dispute about which sample was the reference.
Decide the remedy before you need it
Specify what happens on a failed inspection: rework at the supplier cost with re-inspection, sorting with a discount, or rejection with a refund of the deposit. The option you do not write down is the option you will not get.
Questions buyers ask
Should the acceptance standard be signed by both parties?
Yes, with a date and revision number, and re-signed whenever the design changes. An unsigned specification is advice, not a contract term.
What if the plant cannot measure a tolerance you specified?
Then either the tolerance is wrong or the plant is wrong for that part. A tolerance nobody can verify will be delivered however it comes out.